Did Astroglide change their formula?

I use Astroglide Gel which is thicker but not super-thick, and you could always thin that with a drop or two of water to get the consistency you like. I have little experience with the original formula but I'm pretty sure it's identical outside of the different viscosity. 

I bought a bottle of Astroglide and I found it to be awful. It wasn't slippery and was almost like not having any lube at all. I finally threw it out. To me it is almost worthless. The best that I have found is Walmart's Equate Personal Lubricate Jelly. I've used it when have multiple hour sessions and things are still slick when the session is over. 

@zentai Ditto your comments on Astroglide Gel tube.  It sticks nicely to my toy when I lube it before insertion, and to my finger tip for anus relaxation before.

Astroglide gel all damn day! My go-to for years now. The formula of the gel has stayed the same forever. The liquid version has changed. It sucks. 

I actually use Fleshlight's normal lube for penis play. It lasts a long time, doesn't get tacky too fast, and is very reliable. I can use it in any sleeve-based toys since its water-based with no silicone in it. It does NOT work for anal play though! So its Astroglide gel in me, and Fleshlight lube on me 😉