Hey @helghast,
I'm a bit late to the party but I wanted to thank you too for sharing your experience with us. It read like a sexy fan fiction... in a good way... very hot! 🙂
I just wanted to give you my two cents real quick.
I've mostly felt pain at my second sphincter during his first penetration too
Devine o mentioned the second sphincter too,that must have been it,everything loosened up after a little bit,I’m sure it can only get better.
You should incorporate some stretching in your foreplay. That's one of the things buttplugs where originally designed for. You may do this in 2 or even 3 steps in which you increase the diameter of the plugs / toys. A few minutes with each toy is good enough. The more you practice the better your body gets used to the routine and relaxes faster.
The "second inner sphincter" is made of smooth muscle, meaning that you can't relax it at will. It only reacts to constant pressure... from the inside. Think of your anal canal as an airlock with two doors. The inner door is there to let you know that somthing wants out. That's how you know, that you have to go to the toilet. The inner sphincter relaxes after a while when something pushes against it, so that you have to hold in consciously with your outer sphincter. The longer you wait, the more the inner sphincter relaxes and won't help you with the task, so the more "effort" is needed to keep your dignity in public.
Fun fact: your anal canal does not only consists of two sphincters, but rather five. But that's for another time.
Also: Dildos !
Since you and your wife seem to plan to make this a habit, you should spend some time and money on quality toys. There are vast differences in quality and suitability.
Rules of thumb for a good experience:
Instead of warming up with plugs you can also work your way up with diffently sized dildos. A very good and inexpensive line I can personally recommend is from Blush:
If you are into fantasy toys, check out Lily O'Riley on youtube. That gal is an amazing reviewer (she reviews all kind of toys, not just Bad Dragon style monster dildos).
Say hi to your wife from us and tell her we love her and envy you. 😉
Cheers, Unfug
@unfug thanks mate,we got a few bits already,some on our own,some on recommendation. There will be more gear on the way soon.We fancy some nipple clamps too ha ha I’ll probably end up in a gimp suit!
The bigger softer stuff I hadn’t even considered. I’ve a lot to lean,I’ll check out the link for sure Cheers.