Is it possible to have a Super O without feeling pleasure?

This is an interesting question.
Sometimes I have reactions like other people seem to have physically but while for me it's just "pleasant" or just completely neutral other people are soaked in pleasure.
This is not just from aneros for me but I seem to have the same you do.

I am in the same boat- all the physical movements and pleasant feelings but not in the same league as a traditional orgasm.

@PistolPete79 You have raised an interesting question. IMHO, what I would suggest is to "step back" from your sessions and have no expectations. My recent experiences tells me that I should go into a session not expecting anything. Things can happen there that may completely go against your instincts. Just let go (I know this is hard to do when your expectations are high) and let things happen as they may. Try not to "analyze" the session as you experience it (this is also hard).

Are whole-body shakes pleasurable? A Super-O can be very intense but is it pleasurable? Maybe, maybe not. But in the context of the entire session, all the feelings could be regarded as satisfying and enjoyable!

My opinion, no. I have experienced what you described. I attributed it to excitement, and sometimes even nervousness. Sometimes I'd get the jolts because I'm on he verge of falling asleep because of my relaxation during a session.... If you experience pleasure from a traditional orgasm I don't see how it would be possible for your prostate to orgasm, and for you to not feel pleasure from it.

Now then. I’ve had many orgasms in my experience but my last session was quite different. Using my mxg, insertion was very slightly uncomfortable. I usually stop but this time I thought I would give it a chance. Anyway after about 20 mins I finally relaxed. My body began to build up to super o but i didnt feel much at all. I climaxed but just didn’t feel satisfied. I ended my session ejaculating by hand which as usual felt fantastic. Like goldenboy said, I think I was over analysing the session from the beginning as I was too focused on typing to relax through the discomfort I had from inserting

Jolts are usually not very pleasurable, but the orgasms that follow definitely are. You just have to get there. Relax, it will happen.

I have noticed that a lot of sensations go under the radar when I'm not in the right mood or mindset.

So today, I was able to get in my first Aneros session in a few months. I used the track in the link below and I had so much pleasure during my session. This track is not hypnosis, but rather sounds of women being horny and orgasming. This got me really turned on.

The session, with my Progasm, was pleasurable from beginning to the end. I just laid on my back with my knees up and did nothing. After about a minute, the Progasm began jumping and at some point I began echoing the jumping. Maybe a couple minutes later, my pelvis began trembling, which then led to abdominal shaking. This went on and off for a while. In between waves of abdominal shaking, my pelvis would hold a light vibration that kept the arousal going. This was something new for me. I finished the session after about 45 minutes because I had stuff to do. I don’t think there was a Super O involved, but I did enjoy what I experienced and felt a lot of pleasure. This track will be my go to track for Aneros sessions.

https://soundgasm.net/u/xfeeefeee/Orgasmic-ambience-experiment